A Conceptual Framework for Professional Legitimacy

Construct  1     Moral Legitimacy              

                       Definition                            We reflect the same norms, standards, and values as other respected professions

                       Outcome                             We will be judged on our results, our procedures, the technologies we employ, and our structures, leaders and personnel.

                       Categories                           Consequential Legitimacy
                                                                     Procedural Legitimacy
                                                                     Structural Legitimacy
                                                                     Personal Legitimacy
Construct 2      Pragmatic legitimacy        

                       Definition                            We fulfil the needs and interests of our stakeholders by delivering services to their satisfaction.

                       Outcome                             We need to provide the value and standards that peer professions demand. In exchange, we will receive their support and legitimacy

                       Categories                           Exchange legitimacy
                                                                     Influence legitimacy
                                                                     Dispositional legitimacy
Construct 3     Cognitive legitimacy         

                       Definition                            We pursue goals and activities that fit with broad social understandings of what is appropriate, proper, and desirable for a professional community.

                       Outcome                             We have to “makes sense” to peer professions. Eventually we should be “taken for granted” as a natural part of the professional community.

                       Categories                           Understand-ability
                                                                     Taken-for-Grantedness
                                                                     Trust
                                                                     Respectability
                                                                     Integrity
                                                                     Ethics